hands being held
Mayukh Saha
Mayukh Saha
December 18, 2023 ·  2 min read

We Just Found Out We’re Siblings — But We’re Still Dating

Dating has its challenges, but nothing really prepares you for finding out your partner may be your half-sibling. In fact, this particular couple probably doesn’t even know how to be siblings if they had to. Mercedes and Carley have been dating for two years. Just like anyone else, we’re sure their relationships has had its challenges, but nothing quite like this. In a recent TikTok, the couple revealed that they could be half-siblings. As in, their mothers had relations with the same man. The pair went on to reveal this on their OnlyFans account with the handle @notyouraveragesisterz. The unsettling news was then viewed around 6 million times on TikTok. This also left their half a million followers desperately asking them to get a DNA test done. 

Mercedes and Carley
Image Credit: carleyandmercedes | TikTok

Can these Siblings be Lovers?

The message on the TikTok video read, “When you find out two years into dating that your moms both slept with the same guy. Should we take a DNA test?” The pair further asked their followers, “If we’re actually related is it wrong to stay together?” Thousands of their fans chimed in with their opinions. One user commented, “I think the real risk would be not getting the DNA test.” Another user agreed and reiterated the sentiment. But the dating couple stated, “We’re scared.” 

Mercedes and Carley
Image Credit: carleyandmercedes | TikTok

Another user mentioned, “I have no idea who you guys are and I immediately thought you were sisters before reading the text.” Whereas another commenter stated, “That could explain why you two look like sisters.” One user had a different perspective on this. “Am I the only person who thinks that regardless of the results it doesn’t matter?”

Read: Elon Musk Wonders Whether TikTok Is Destroying Civilization

@carleyandmercedes Should we take a DNA test? #siblingsordating #fyp #foryou #wlw #xyzbca ♬ original sound – szasgrandchildren

In their latest video on TikTok, the couple had some updates to share. They stated that they would be thinking about having a DNA test done. They have since completed a 23&Me test, but are awaiting results. What do you think they should do once they find out? Let us know in the comments!

@carleyandmercedes Reply to @_hi_im_kendra_ wish us luck 🤞🏼 #fyp #foryou #wlw #xyzbca ♬ original sound – Carley&Mercedes

Keep Reading: Survey shows older women are now dating younger men. Here’s why.


  1. We just found out we’re siblings — but we’re still dating.” New York Post. Emily Lefroy. June 21, 2022.
  2. carleyandmercedes. TikTok. June 17, 2022